The Lip Smacker Coca-Cola Vintage Tin Collection is currently the more expensive option, sitting notably higher than the NYX Smushy Matte Lip Balm — which remains the budget-friendly single-product pick at a fraction of the price, making the per-item cost on the Lip Smacker set the real deciding factor right now.
Buy the Lip Smacker Coca-Cola Vintage Tin if you want a fun gift set, love novelty packaging, or want multiple flavours to try at a low per-balm cost. Buy the NYX Smushy Matte Lip Balm if you want a single buildable colour product with a soft matte finish for daily makeup use.
If you want everyday matte colour with a hydrating formula, the NYX Smushy Matte Lip Balm at £4.00 is the stronger single-use buy. But if you need a gift or want variety across flavours, the Lip Smacker Coca-Cola Tin at £6.48 delivers exceptional value with six balms in a collectible tin — it's hard to beat at just over £1 per balm.
The table below compares both balms across key factors including quantity, finish, hydration claims, packaging, flavour/shade options, and overall value per unit.
| Product | Price | Was | Discount | Status | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lip Smacker Coca-Cola Vintage Tin Gift Set down to £6.65, 41... | £6.69 | £11.29 | 41% off | Tracked | |
| NYX Smushy Matte Lip Balm in She Is Serving down 29% at Amaz... | £7.99 | — | — | Tracked |
Historically, the NYX Smushy Matte has held a consistently low and stable price point with occasional dips around seasonal beauty sales, while the Lip Smacker Coca-Cola Tin tends to see its best discounts in the run-up to Christmas and Valentine's Day when gift sets are most heavily promoted.
